25 April, 2014 02:20 IST
Gold import duty hike tackles the symptom, not the cause: Varma
Source: IRIS (22-JAN-13)
Comments  |  Post Comment

The government raised the import duty on gold from 4% to 6% in order to check gold imports. We expect gold imports value to ease to USD 44 billion in FY14 from an estimated USD 48.3 billion in FY13, or a drop of 0.2% points.

``We expect the current account deficit to moderate to 4.3% of GDP in FY14 from an estimated 4.9% in FY13, remaining above sustainable levels, due to high oil prices and continued domestic supply-side constraints boosting import demand,`` said Sonal Varma, economist, Nomura. ``Gold demand has risen as a hedge against inflation. Therefore, we think imposing import duty will likely only shift gold imports from official to unofficial channels as it tackles the symptom, not the cause.``

Will this help curb gold imports and, if so, by how much?

``In the past, imposition of import duty has had some salutary effect in moderating official gold imports. In March 2012, the government doubled the import duty on gold from 2% to 4%. As a result, gold import volumes contracted by around 25% y-o-y during the first three quarters of 2012. In volume terms, we expect India's gold imports to fall to 855 mt (metric ton) in FY13 from 891 mt in FY12; and to USD 48 billion from USD 56 billion in value terms. The additional imposition of import duty could lead to gold imports moderating to 750-800 mt in FY14. However, we do not expect gold imports to fall much more than that as consumption demand for gold (around 65% of gold demand) and investment demand (35%) have already moderated close to their averages. Given India's penchant for gold for weddings and other religious ceremonies, a sharp fall in volumes is unlikely, in our view. With gold prices hovering around USD 1680/oz, we expect gold imports value to ease to USD 44 billion in FY14 from USD 48.3 billion in FY13, or a drop of 0.2% points.``

Will this help tame the current account deficit?

``Gold imports are not entirely responsible for the widening current account deficit (CAD). In FY13 (Apr-Sep), net exports of gold moderated to USD 9.1 billion from USD 25.1 billion in FY12, yet the current account deficit is likely to widen to a new record of USD 90 billion or 4.9% of GDP in FY13, in our view. While gold imports have fallen, higher oil prices, weak exports, flagging invisibles balance and inelastic demand for imports of coal, fertilizer and other commodities have led to a sharp rise in India's current account deficit. With exports likely to recover in 2013, we expect India`s current account deficit to improve but to remain around 4.3% of GDP in FY14, much above sustainable levels (of 2.5% of GDP), due to high oil prices and continued domestic supply-side constraints boosting import demand.``

``One of the reasons why households have a penchant for gold is that it has provided the best return among all financial instruments during a period of high inflation. Apart from high real returns, it is also the most liquid asset. Unless investors have options on other financial instruments, which provide an inflation hedge, we think import duties will only lead to a reduction in gold imports through the official channel and result in a simultaneous rise in gold imports through unofficial channels. Therefore, in our view imposing import duty tackles the symptom, not the cause.``

Disclaimer: IRIS has taken due care and caution in compilation of data for its web site. Information has been obtained by IRIS from sources which it considers reliable. However, IRIS does not guarantee the accuracy, adequacy or completeness of any information and is not responsible for any errors or omissions or for the results obtained from the use of such information. IRIS especially states that it has no financial liability whatsoever to any user on account of the use of information provided on its website.

Tata Metaliks loss narrows in Jan-Mar quarter - 24-Apr-2014 16:32
Granules India standalone quarterly net up 13.26% - 24-Apr-2014 16:29
ACC standalone quarterly net declines 8.9% - 24-Apr-2014 15:42
Oil Country Tubular standalone quarterly earnings soar 65.48 times - 24-Apr-2014 15:36
Bharti Infratel standalone quarterly net surges 40.64% - 24-Apr-2014 15:30
Infotech Enterprises standalone quarterly earnings rise 28.81% - 24-Apr-2014 15:22
UltraTech Cement standalone quarterly net climbs 15.40% - 23-Apr-2014 18:38
Indiabulls Wholesale Services standalone quarterly net falls 35.05% - 23-Apr-2014 18:36
Kirloskar Pneumatic Company standalone quarterly earnings rise 18.78% - 23-Apr-2014 18:32
Indbank Merchant Banking Services swings to profit in Jan-Mar quarter - 23-Apr-2014 18:23
Sabero Organics Gujarat standalone quarterly net declines 27.22% - 23-Apr-2014 17:32
* Q - Quote , N - News , C - Chart , F - Financials
Comments Post comment 
 Post Comment
Name Email
Security Code type   gm9qqz into this box
Home  |   Shares  |   F&O  |   Mutual Funds  |   Loans  |   Insurance  |   News Centre
Wealth Tracker  |   Newsletters  |   Tax Corner  |   NRI Centre  |   Forums  |   E-mail  |   Advertise
© All rights reserved. IRIS Business Services Limited
A Disclaimer